In a world full of distractions and pressures, finding stories that speak directly to teens’ hearts—while pointing them toward faith, hope, and real-life wisdom—is invaluable for youth pastors, leaders, and parents. If you’re searching for the best books for youth groups this year, When Darkness Tries to Hide by Stacy A. Padula stands out as a compelling, discussion-rich choice that combines gripping storytelling with powerful spiritual truths.
A Story That Mirrors Real Teen Life
Set in the halls of Montgomery Lake High, this second book in the award-winning Montgomery Lake High series follows a group of students rocked by a tragic storm and a classmate’s life hanging in the balance. At the center is Jason Davids, a popular teen battling emptiness, substance use, guilt, and the pull of a party lifestyle. As darkness—both literal and emotional—closes in, Jason and his friends must confront hard choices about friendship, peer pressure, forgiveness, and where true fulfillment comes from.
What makes this book especially relevant for today’s teens? It doesn’t shy away from real struggles like addiction, cliques, identity, and hidden pain. Instead, it shows the raw consequences while illuminating a path forward through community, accountability, and faith. Readers often describe it as “relatable,” “urgent,” and “impossible to put down.”
Perfect for Youth Group Discussions and Growth
Youth leaders love When Darkness Tries to Hide because it naturally sparks meaningful conversations. Key themes include:
- Light vs. Darkness — How God brings hope even in life’s storms.
- Redemption and Second Chances — Jason’s journey shows that no one is beyond grace.
- The Power of Community — Cliques dissolve as students come together to support one another.
- Faith in Action — Characters lean on prayer, wise counsel (like Pastor Mark), and positive influences, modeling real spiritual growth.
Churches and youth groups use it for book studies, small group discussions, or as a supplement to teachings on temptation, peer pressure, and walking in the light. It’s accessible as a standalone read but connects beautifully to the full Montgomery Lake High and Gripped series for deeper exploration.
Teens and reviewers frequently share how the book helped them process their own challenges, strengthened their relationship with God, and encouraged them to surround themselves with supportive friends. One teen reader noted it equips readers with tools to overcome real high school pressures.
Why It Belongs on Your Youth Group Reading List This Year
- Authentic Christian YA — Written by an author with deep roots in teen ministry and counseling, the story feels genuine rather than preachy.
- Award-Winning and Timeless — Part of a series with strong reader acclaim and Gold Award recognition for Best Teen Book in the Readers’ Choice Book Awards.
- Engaging for Multiple Ages — Ideal for middle and high school students, with insights valuable for leaders and parents too.
- Hope-Filled Message — In a culture that often highlights darkness, this book leaves readers with lasting light and practical encouragement.
If your youth group is looking for stories that entertain, challenge, and disciple, When Darkness Tries to Hide delivers. It’s more than a novel—it’s a tool for transformation.
Ready to Dive in With Your Youth Group or Classroom?
Get 15 copies of When Darkness Tries to Hide at a special discount using this link
Download our free companion study guide to use with your youth group
For more about the series, check out the full Montgomery Lake High collection or the connected Gripped series, which expands these characters’ journeys with even more redemption and real-talk on addiction and faith.
Stacy A. Padula, a native of Pembroke, Massachusetts, is an award-winning author, educator, and entrepreneur known for her impactful young adult and children’s book series. She began writing her first series, Montgomery Lake High, as a teenager, addressing critical issues like substance abuse and bullying. Her ongoing Gripped series, a prequel and sequel to her first is being adapted for TV by Emmy-winning producer Mark Blutman. Padula also co-authored the On the Right Path children’s series with NBA coach Brett Gunning, endorsed by figures like Kevin McHale, Mike D’Antoni, and Joel Osteen. Named “Young Adult Author of the Year” by IAOTP and “Woman of the Year” by The CIO Times, Padula’s work continues to inspire and educate globally.
Discover more from Books by Stacy A. Padula
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
